Download pdf show page numbers originating in linguistics phonemic vs. Reflecting on the tensions between emic and etic perspectives in life history research. Emic and etic principle free download as powerpoint presentation. An emic view, for example, will enable you to explain all the nuances of finding a spouse in pakistan, or how u. I utilized a life history methodology in this study through which written and oral narratives were obtained from six postsecondary students who selfidentified as lesbian, gay, bisexual, andor queer lgbq. What is the difference between emic and etic approaches. For example, if an american anthropologist went to africa to study a nomadic tribe, hisher resulting case study would be from an etic standpoint if heshe did not integrate themselves into the culture they were observing. An emic perspective is fundamental to understanding how people perceive the world around them.
Start studying explain, using examples, emic and etic concepts. A useful example of the emic etic distinction may be made by comparing the concept waves on the ocean or. The detached observer has one view, the native participant has another, but both are necessary. Minimum of 2 scholarly sources 1 for the etic view, and 1 for the emic view. Qualitative researchers often begin by asking people openended. One way is looking at things through an emic approach. Etic and emic approaches two main approaches are frequently discussed in crosscultural literature. Insiders and outsiders to social issues is a concept that is an integral part of participatory action research, which emphasizes the partnering and working together with people who are closest to the problem by dint of personal experience and.
It has been viewed epidemiologically as population. The difference between the emic and etic study approach. A linguistic and philosophical analysis of emic and etic. Eating christmas in the kalahari lee is about a anthropologist having christmas in the bush with the. The insiders perception of reality is instrumental to understanding and accurately describing situations and behaviors. Explain, using examples, emic and etic concepts flashcards. Ethnographers use both the emic and etic perspectives. A phonemic analysis examines the significant sounds in a given language, those complex sounds that differentiate meaning in the language and build up the words of the language. Background the terms emic and etic were first used by the linguist kenneth l. Emic and etic approaches of understanding behavior and personality fall under the study of cultural anthropology. The emic perspective strives to understand humans from an insider pointof view, while the etic takes an objective outsiders pointof view. Emic and etic some research terminology file fetch121863468research%20terminologies. Emic and etic are two different approaches when trying to explain social realities observed while conducting fieldwork in anthropology and other social sciences.
Franklinetic and emic stories graduate institute of. In the etic perspective, the researcher looks at the research field objectively from a distance. Etic researchers are quantitatively oriented, look for causal explanations of cultural behavior, and are interested in discovering universal patterns of behavior. Etic perspective is the perspective of the observer. This paper argues, based on personal construct theory, that behavioral type measures or scales must be examined within each cultural domain to determine if the construct and its. Etic, rather than simply emic views, can help us understand reality. Obtaining an emic view of another culture is a central goal of doing ethnography, and an emic view is necessary before an etic perspective can truly be obtained. The emic perspective the insiders or natives perspective of reality is at the heart of most ethnographic research. A stereoscopic view etic and emic are two ways to view the same thing, resulting in two ways to describe it, providing, as pike 1957 says, a stereoscopic window on the world. University of leeds introduction herodotus, writing in the fifth century b. Nonecumenical studies in medical morality, 211, 7383. Pike in a study entitled language in relation to a unified theory of the structure of human behavior, published in 1967.
The paper briefly discusses the nature of emic and etic. An etic view of a culture is the perspective of an outsider looking in. Second stage, researchers may interpret early findings by using emic perspective from other cultures. The etic approach is a nonstructural analysis concerned with 1 universals that may be described with some sort of 2 physical component eventually organized in some form of 3 typology for language, this typology is the international phonetic alphabet, or ipa. On one level, we cannot attain an insider view of rose. In the final stage, the researcher tests an explanation constructed from etic approach. Your source for the emic view should come from someone who writes with authority in the religion you chose. Interpreting the hebrew scriptures a tangential issue that must be addressed is the idea that the negative language the gospels direct against jews represents nothing more than a family squabble, or conflicts between different groups of first century jews, and does not reflect gentile christians speaking ill of jews. The terms etic and emic are indeed the truncated versions of the distinctive linguistic categories phonemic and phonetic. The research strategy that focuses on local explanations and criteria of significance. Changing the face of multicultural counselling with.
This two ways of obtaining data can be applied in numerous areas. Emic perspective can be defined as the perspective in which the researcher gains the insiders point of view. First, original exploratory research relies on etic concepts and measurement methods from the researchers home culture. We use the leadership effectiveness in africa and the african diaspora lead research project to explicate the cycle that we propose. Cultural anthropology states that people are shaped by their cultures and their subcultures, and we must account for this in the study of personality. This allows us qualitative data data regarding the. Within the field of intercultural behavior there are two research approaches. New perspectives on vulnerability using emic and etic approaches the concept of vulnerability has not been developed theoretically from a nursing perspective. Emic data procure subjective meanings the kind of data you can only get by asking deep questions and engaging in participant observation. The debate around emic etic approaches in general represents a clear divide, with preference for either the emic or the etic as the.
An emic perspective is the insiders view of reality. The subsequent will look at readings that give examples of etic and emic studies. Although berry views emic insight as an important initial step in comparative analysis, his derived etic approach sidelines the emic in the end. A roman catholic and an emic etic approach to a religious polemic. Furthermore, the etic view does not perceive all aspects of a situation to be part of a larger setting. While this perspective stems from the concept of immersion in a specific culture, the emic participant isnt always a member of that culture or society. It is one of the principal concepts guiding qualitative research.
Conversely, the emic approach tends to be culturespecific and applied to one culture or language at a. Emic and etic perspectives the emic and etic perspectives have equally long pedigrees in social science. An etic perspective is about an individual viewing a culture or subculture in the perspective of an outsider. Instructions make sure to read the lesson this week. Results data were reported as percentages emic description of mental disorder centering on physical symptoms the participants were fairly knowledgeable about western etic mental health models 63% viewed agression as a main symptom of abnormality 25% of the participats. Todays lesson on emic and etic approaches to studying human culture will be both complicated and simple. The research strategy that emphasizes the ethnographers rather than the locals explanation, categories, and criteria of significance. Buckley, malcolm chapman, jeremy clegg, hanna gajewskade mattos. A number of authors have suggested that multicultural counselling is a new paradigm in counselling ivey et al.
A linguistic and philosophical analysis of emic and etic and their use in international business research. The emic or inside perspective follows in the tradition of psychological studies of folk beliefs wundt, 1888 and in cultural anthropologists striving to understand culture from the natives point of view malinowski, 1922. Using examples, explain emic and etic concepts prezi. Itll be complicated because the terms emic and etic are unfamiliar to most of us.
On the emic etic question, i think it is quite possible to make a case for both. For instance, etic and emic perspective can be used to gain a better understanding of the religious aspects of the catholic church. Instead, etic data can be obtained through analysis of partial information. Difference between emic and etic compare the difference. The emic and etic perspectives ethnographers seek to gain an emic perspective, or the natives point of view of a specific culture hammersley and atkinson, 2007. Etic and emic investigations both have their pros and cons, and together they compliment and support each other. A read is counted each time someone views a publication summary such as the title, abstract, and list of authors, clicks on a figure, or views or downloads the fulltext. For example, if you chose buddhism, you could use a quotation from his holiness, dalai lama xiv. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. An emic view of culture is ultimately a perspective focus on the intrinsic cultural distinctions that are meaningful to the members of a given society, often considered to be an insiders perspective. A major issue is the so called emic versus etic dilemma which focuses on whether or not the measure is culture bound emic or can be used across all cultures etic.
1046 1377 624 668 497 340 802 338 1172 672 398 796 929 316 956 357 226 169 112 1528 112 1397 1118 433 306 505 1100 221 313 670 465 1252 854 156 911 745 385 427 1106 1271 604 731 1272